HomeJourneyResources
Comparing World Religions

Other Religions

How does Christianity compare to Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Judaism, and Atheism? Examine claims, evidence, and differences respectfully.

Read Full Resource
5
Religions Compared
8
Comparison Points
68,000+
Word Count
5 hours
Reading Time

Why Christianity?

If Christianity is true, what makes it different from Buddhism, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, and atheism? This is the question thoughtful seekers ask.

This resource examines major world religions, compares their truth claims fairly, and evaluates which evidence best supports the claims made. The goal isn't to insult or demean other traditions but to demonstrate why Christianity makes claims no other religion makes—and backs them with evidence no other religion can match.

Evaluation Criteria: Founder's claims, historical evidence, prophecy, testability, logical coherence, transformative power, archaeological confirmation, textual reliability.

Comparison Matrix

Rate each religion's similarity to Christianity (1 = Very Different, 5 = Very Similar)

Religions Assessed0 / 5 (0%)

Islam

1.8 billion followers

Founder: Muhammad (570-632 AD)

Muhammad is the final prophet. God (Allah) is strictly one. Jesus was a prophet but not divine. Quran is God's final revelation.

Evidence for Claims:

  • Muhammad existed as historical figure
  • Quran preserved with textual consistency
  • Islamic civilization spread rapidly
  • No claimed miracles by Muhammad (Quran doesn't record miracles)
  • No bodily resurrection of Muhammad
  • No specific fulfilled prophecies establishing Muhammad's authority

Key Differences:

  • Jesus: Islam says prophet only. Christianity says Son of God, divine.
  • Crucifixion: Islam denies Jesus died. Christianity central—Jesus died and rose.
  • Resurrection: Islam denies. Christianity affirms bodily resurrection.
  • Salvation: Islam = works/obedience. Christianity = grace through faith.
  • God's nature: Islam = strictly one, no son. Christianity = Trinity.
  • Prophecy: No OT prophecies predict Muhammad. 300+ predict Jesus.

Common Ground:

  • One God exists (monotheism)
  • Judgment after death
  • Morality matters
  • Jesus born of virgin, will return
  • Prophets conveyed God's message
  • Scripture is important
Rate similarity to Christianity:

Buddhism

500 million followers

Founder: Siddhartha Gautama (563-483 BC)

Buddha achieved enlightenment. All existence is suffering. Goal is Nirvana—escape rebirth. Individual self (Atman) is illusion.

Evidence for Claims:

  • Buddha existed historically
  • Teachings documented (but 300+ years after Buddha)
  • No claimed miracles or resurrection
  • No fulfilled prophecies
  • Enlightenment is subjective and unverifiable
  • Reincarnation assumed, not proven

Key Differences:

  • Creator: Buddhism = no creator, eternal cycles. Christianity = God created all.
  • Self: Buddhism = self is illusion. Christianity = self is real, eternally valued.
  • Goal: Buddhism = escape existence (Nirvana). Christianity = relationship with God.
  • Resurrection: Buddhism = no concept. Christianity = bodily resurrection.
  • Suffering: Buddhism = escape it. Christianity = God redeems it.
  • Testability: Buddhism = subjective claims. Christianity = historical resurrection.

Common Ground:

  • Spiritual reality exists
  • Material isn't all there is
  • Contemplative practice has value
  • Ethics matter
  • Individual transformation possible
Rate similarity to Christianity:

Hinduism

1.2 billion followers

Founder: No single founder (ancient tradition)

Multiple paths to liberation (moksha). Ultimate reality is Brahman (impersonal or personal). Reincarnation based on karma. Atman (self) is divine or illusion.

Evidence for Claims:

  • Ancient texts (Vedas 1500-500 BC, Upanishads 800-200 BC)
  • Philosophical sophistication
  • No specific founder to verify
  • Mythology mixed with history
  • No testable miracles by founders
  • No specific fulfilled prophecies
  • Reincarnation assumed, no evidence

Key Differences:

  • Divine nature: Hinduism = impersonal Brahman or multiple deities. Christianity = personal God.
  • Self: Hinduism = Atman is illusion/divine spark. Christianity = self is real, created.
  • Goal: Hinduism = escape rebirth, merge with Brahman. Christianity = relationship with God.
  • Salvation: Hinduism = works across lifetimes. Christianity = grace in one lifetime.
  • Resurrection: Hinduism = reincarnation. Christianity = one life, then resurrection.
  • Ethics: Hinduism = contextual (karma/dharma). Christianity = absolute (God's character).

Common Ground:

  • Spiritual reality exists
  • Divine/transcendent reality acknowledged
  • Personal transformation valued
  • Meditation/contemplation has value
Rate similarity to Christianity:

Judaism

15 million followers

Founder: Abraham, Moses (patriarchs/prophets)

One God gave Torah. Jewish people are God's chosen. Messiah is still to come. Jesus was not the Messiah.

Evidence for Claims:

  • Shares Hebrew Bible with Christianity
  • Historical documentation strong
  • Archaeological confirmation of biblical events
  • Messianic prophecy exists (but dispute: fulfilled or future?)
  • No claimed resurrection of Abraham/Moses
  • 300+ messianic prophecies point to Jesus (Christian interpretation)

Key Differences:

  • Messiah: Judaism = still awaited. Christianity = Jesus is Messiah.
  • Jesus: Judaism = teacher or misguided. Christianity = Son of God, Savior.
  • Resurrection: Judaism = general resurrection awaited. Christianity = Jesus rose first.
  • Sacrifice: Judaism = temple sacrifice (ended 70 AD). Christianity = Jesus final sacrifice.
  • Salvation: Judaism = Torah observance + God's mercy. Christianity = grace through faith.
  • Gentiles: Judaism = not central. Christianity = gospel for all nations.

Common Ground:

  • One God exists (monotheism)
  • Torah is God's revelation
  • Prophets spoke God's word
  • Resurrection will occur
  • Judgment comes
  • Ethics matter deeply
Rate similarity to Christianity:

Atheism/Materialism

Varies (450-500 million estimated) followers

Founder: Various philosophers (no single founder)

Only physical matter exists. No God. No spiritual reality. Meaning is subjective. Death ends existence.

Evidence for Claims:

  • Science explains natural phenomena naturalistically
  • No empirical proof of God's existence
  • Problem of evil challenges God's existence
  • Evolution explains life without designer
  • Consciousness may emerge from matter (though unsolved)

Key Differences:

  • God: Atheism = no God exists. Christianity = God exists, revealed in Jesus.
  • Meaning: Atheism = subjective, human-created. Christianity = objective, grounded in God.
  • Morality: Atheism = subjective opinion. Christianity = objective, grounded in God.
  • Consciousness: Atheism = emergent from matter (unproven). Christianity = grounded in God's consciousness.
  • Death: Atheism = cessation of existence. Christianity = resurrection and eternity.
  • Fine-tuning: Atheism = coincidence. Christianity = design.

Common Ground:

  • Science is valuable
  • Reason matters
  • Ethics matter (though atheism struggles to ground them objectively)
  • Honest investigation is important
Rate similarity to Christianity:

What Makes Christianity Unique

God Became Human

Jesus is God incarnate—fully God, fully human. Islam/Judaism deny. Buddhism/Hinduism debate avatars.

Bodily Resurrection

Jesus died and rose bodily. No other founder claimed or achieved this. Resurrection proves divinity.

Fulfilled Prophecy

300+ specific predictions written centuries before fulfillment. Statistically impossible by chance.

Salvation by Grace

Freely given forgiveness through faith. All other religions require works/obedience/effort.

Personal Relationship

God knows us personally, wants relationship. Not distant deity or impersonal force.

Eternal Personhood

Resurrection body, eternal relationship with God. Self is preserved, not dissolved or escaped.

The Resurrection is Christianity's Hinge Point

If Jesus rose from death: God exists, Jesus is God's Son, His death atoned for sin, Christianity is exclusively true, we will be resurrected too. If Jesus didn't rise: Christianity is false. The stakes could not be higher.

Ready for a Deeper Dive?

Explore the complete 68,000+ word resource with detailed comparisons, conversation guides, testimonies from former Muslims/Buddhists/Hindus/Atheists, and respectful engagement strategies.

Read the Complete Resource
5 religions comparedConversation guides includedConversion testimonies